Brooklyn Botany Brown Sugar Body Scrub - Moisturizing and Exfoliating Body, Face, Hand, Foot Scrub - Fights Acne, Fine Lines &…
Brooklyn Botany
Best for
Best budget
Amazon rating
Amazon aggregate, one input among many in the Verdict Score
Current price
$9.99
Updated May 18, 2026 · 1 min read
Sources behind this verdict
10 reviewers weighted by source trust
The consensus
What reviewers found
Synthesized across the trust-weighted source mix below.
Across the reviewers we read, Brooklyn Botany's Brown Sugar Body Scrub is the budget pick that specialist communities actually recommend rather than tolerate. A thread in r/30PlusSkinCare explicitly calls it a "good enough dupe" for pricier scrubs at a fraction of the cost, and r/MakeupAddictionCanada commenters say it works well on keratosis pilaris and leaves skin notably smoother. r/Forever35 has a similar take, framing it as a TikTok-driven impulse buy that turned into a repurchase.
What reviewers liked
- Specialist subreddits (r/30PlusSkinCare, r/Forever35, r/MakeupAddictionCanada) recommend it by name as a budget option
- Verified reviewers in r/MakeupAddictionCanada specifically cite improvement on keratosis pilaris
- Large 10 oz jar under $10 with 15K+ Amazon reviews
- Brown sugar grit is gentle enough that reviewers report tolerating it multiple times per week
Where it falls short
- Walmart and Amazon verified reviewers report oil separation in the jar requiring stirring
- r/Indiemakeupandmore commenters say the exfoliation is too mild for those who want serious grit
- Marketed as face-safe, but specialist skincare communities generally discourage gritty scrubs on facial skin
- Scent intensity varies by batch per retailer reviews
Across the reviewers we read, Brooklyn Botany's Brown Sugar Body Scrub is the budget pick that specialist communities actually recommend rather than tolerate. A thread in r/30PlusSkinCare explicitly calls it a "good enough dupe" for pricier scrubs at a fraction of the cost, and r/MakeupAddictionCanada commenters say it works well on keratosis pilaris and leaves skin notably smoother. r/Forever35 has a similar take, framing it as a TikTok-driven impulse buy that turned into a repurchase.
The weaknesses are honest ones. Walmart and Amazon verified-purchase reviewers note the jar arrives separated and needs stirring, and r/Indiemakeupandmore commenters describe the grit as less aggressive than they'd like — fine if you want gentle, frustrating if you want a serious polish. The brand markets it as face-safe, but specialist skincare subreddits generally caution against any gritty physical scrub on facial skin regardless of marketing.
No high-trust testing publisher appears in the supplied signals here, so the case rests on retailer-verified volume and specialist-community endorsement. On those terms, it earns the budget slot decisively over the unbranded sub-$10 alternatives in the pool.
- Exfoliating & Moisturizing Facial & Body Scrub
- Our Brown Sugar Body Scrub and Face Scrub is a gentle sugar scrub that can be used as a Facial Scrub, Body Scrub, Foot, and Hand Scrub. It is a triple action body and face exfoliator and moisturizer. Containing only pure and natural ingredients, it acts as a natural exfoliator removing dead skin, and moisturizing to reveal fresher healthier clear skin.
- Great For Sensitive Skin
- While salt scrubs may be too harsh for sensitive skin, this Brown Sugar Scrub is a great facial scrub exfoliator and for sensitive skin. It is softer than regular sugar scrubs, while remaining strong enough to scrub away dead skin cells and make way for the healthier, glowing clear skin. Use our Brown Sugar Facial Scrub, Body Scrub, Foot, and Hand Scrub for moisturized smooth skin.
- A VERSATILE SKIN CARE MUST HAVE! Our Brown Sugar Body Scrub and Facial Scrub is perfect for all your skin care needs. This facial scrub and body exfoliator can help clear pimples, blackheads, and bumps on your back, face, and body, making it a must have in your skincare routine. You can use it as both an exfoliator and moisturizer, and it smells great! It can also be used as a lip scrub.
- Nourishing Moisturizer
- While certain exfoliating scrubs or dry brushes can leave your skin dry and dull, Brown Sugar Facial Scrub, Body Scrub, Foot, and Hand Scrub is actually moisturizing. Brown Sugar helps to keep the moisture in your skin locked in. It’s perfect for use before or after waxing and as a foot scrub.
- Proudly Made In Usa
- Our Brown Sugar Facial Scrub, Body Scrub, Foot and Hand Scrub is made in NY, USA using only the highest quality ingredients. It does not contain alcohol, parabens, or sulfates. It is All-Natural, Vegan, and Cruelty Free.
However, the Brooklyn Botany Brown Sugar Scrub is a good enough dupe, plus it's cheap. I also like the Bliss Lemon & Sage Body Polish.
While their sugar exfoliant is more scrubby, it's not enough for my taste, and lacks the moisturizing aspects of the bubbling scrub. What are ...
Trust tier reflects our editorial assessment of the source, not the individual quote. Hover for the rationale. See how we tier sources →
“BROOKLYN BOTANY Brown Sugar Scrub” · Review
If the consensus convinced you
Check current price on Amazon
Pricing and availability change frequently. Tap through to confirm before buying.