Then I Met You Living Cleansing Balm, Makeup Remover, Cleansing Oil, Face Cleanser, Melts Makeup & Sunscreen, Non-Stripping Zero…
Then I Met You
Best for
Best balm (Banila Co Clean It Zero alternative)
Amazon rating
Amazon aggregate, one input among many in the Verdict Score
Based on 2 trusted sources
Current price
$39.00
Updated May 18, 2026 · 1 min read
Sources behind this verdict
10 reviewers weighted by source trust
The consensus
What reviewers found
Synthesized across the trust-weighted source mix below.
Across the reviewers we read, Then I Met You's Living Cleansing Balm is the most consistently praised premium balm in the category. A high-trust r/SkincareAddiction review-roundup thread calls it 'the best cleansing balm I've ever tried,' and a high-trust r/AsianBeauty thread is dedicated entirely to people searching for cheaper dupes, itself a strong consensus signal. Retailer reviews on thenimetyou.com and sokoglam.com echo the sorbet-soft texture, clean rinse, and ability to dissolve waterproof makeup.
What reviewers liked
- High-trust r/SkincareAddiction consensus rates it among the best balms tested
- Reviewers consistently describe a sorbet-soft texture that rinses without residue
- Effective on waterproof makeup and sunscreen per multiple retailer reviews
- Strong dupe-search demand in r/AsianBeauty signals genuine cult status
Where it falls short
- Price near $40 is the dominant criticism across community threads
- Used quickly relative to jar size per r/AsianBeauty users
- Outlier Sephora review reports poor makeup-removal performance
- Fragrance and 'fancy plant oils' criticized as not load-bearing by skeptics
Across the reviewers we read, Then I Met You's Living Cleansing Balm is the most consistently praised premium balm in the category. A high-trust r/SkincareAddiction review-roundup thread calls it 'the best cleansing balm I've ever tried,' and a high-trust r/AsianBeauty thread is dedicated entirely to people searching for cheaper dupes, itself a strong consensus signal. Retailer reviews on thenimetyou.com and sokoglam.com echo the sorbet-soft texture, clean rinse, and ability to dissolve waterproof makeup.
The disagreement is on value, not performance. A high-trust r/SkincareAddiction commenter argues no rinse-off product justifies a near-$40 price tag, and a Sephora retailer review reports it failed to remove light foundation and mascara, an outlier worth surfacing. The synthesis: reviewers who prioritize texture, scent, and a luxury-tier first-step ritual rate it as a category leader; reviewers focused on cost-per-ounce push back hard.
- Award-Winning, Melts Makeup Without Stripping Skin
- Our award-winning sorbet-soft cleansing balm removes sunscreen, long-wear makeup, environmental pollutants, and excess oil effortlessly; it emulsifies with water and rinses clean without residue, prepping your skin for the second step of your routine
- Plant-Based Oils That Support Skin Barrier Health
- Formulated with grape seed, olive, and seaberry oils rich in fatty acids and antioxidants; these ingredients nourish and calm the skin while supporting long-term barrier integrity, leaving a light and hydrated finish.
- Brightens, Balances, And Elevates Your Cleansing Ritual
- This antioxidant-rich blend of vitamin E and persimmon helps illuminate dullness, even skin tone, and protect against environmental stress; paired with a sorbet-soft balm texture and subtle notes of rosemary and grapefruit, it transforms cleansing into a calming, sensorial experience.
- FOR ALL SKIN TYPES, FROM SENSITIVE, DRY SKIN TO OILY, ACNE-PRONE SKIN: Our nourishing, non-stripping cleanser gently yet effectively cleanses skin of all oil-based impurities, and prevents pore-clogging, a major cause of acne, while working to reduce irritation and inflammation in skin; it starts as a balm and melts into a silky oil for a clean, comfortable finish.
- Ethically Formulated For Conscious Skincare
- This vegan, cruelty-free balm, winner of Allure Best of Beauty, Byrdie, and Soko Glam awards, is crafted without polyethylene, mineral oil, alcohol, silicones, parabens, synthetic fragrance, or artificial dyes, reflecting a clean beauty standard for balanced, healthy-looking skin.
No, no rinse off product is worth almost $40 in my opinion. It contains a bunch of fancy and obscure plant oils, but they don't stay on your ...
It feels like such a treat. Smells and feels amazing, and rinses off perfectly without leaving a film or being stripping. Anyone who likes the ...
Trust tier reflects our editorial assessment of the source, not the individual quote. Hover for the rationale. See how we tier sources →
“then i met you living cleansing balm” · trial + review
If the consensus convinced you
Check current price on Amazon
Pricing and availability change frequently. Tap through to confirm before buying.