stila Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, Stay All Day Makeup with Fine Brush Tip Lasting Satin Finish, Smudge-Proof & Transfer-Resistant
Best for
Best liquid (pen-tip)
Amazon rating
Amazon aggregate, one input among many in the Verdict Score
Based on 1 trusted source
Current price
$24.00
Updated May 18, 2026 · 1 min read
Sources behind this verdict
10 reviewers weighted by source trust
The consensus
What reviewers found
Synthesized across the trust-weighted source mix below.
Across the reviewers we read, Stila's Stay All Day is the reference point that other liquid liners get compared against. The marker-style brush tip is repeatedly praised for precision on wings and thin lash-line work, and helplesswhilstdrying.com calls the formula 'incredibly long wearing,' though that same review pushes back on the fully-waterproof claim. Sephora and Ulta product pages echo the 'goes on smoothly, lasts all day' sentiment, and r/Makeup commenters say it stays put so well that removal is the bigger challenge.
What reviewers liked
- Mainstream beauty press and specialist subreddits consistently praise the fine marker-tip for clean wings
- Verified-purchase reviewers report all-day wear with minimal smudging when fresh
- Removal-resistant enough that reviewers call it genuinely long-wearing, not just smudge-proof
Where it falls short
- r/Sephora and r/Ulta threads repeatedly flag units arriving dried out or going watery within weeks
- helplesswhilstdrying.com pushes back on the 'waterproof' marketing claim
- At $24 it's one of the priciest picks, and r/MakeupAddiction users say drugstore pens have closed the gap
Across the reviewers we read, Stila's Stay All Day is the reference point that other liquid liners get compared against. The marker-style brush tip is repeatedly praised for precision on wings and thin lash-line work, and helplesswhilstdrying.com calls the formula 'incredibly long wearing,' though that same review pushes back on the fully-waterproof claim. Sephora and Ulta product pages echo the 'goes on smoothly, lasts all day' sentiment, and r/Makeup commenters say it stays put so well that removal is the bigger challenge.
The disagreement is real and worth surfacing: across r/Sephora and r/Ulta threads, multiple users report recent units arriving dry or going watery within weeks, with one r/MakeupAddiction thread specifically questioning whether the formula has degraded. That QC inconsistency, plus the $24 price tag, is the main reason long-time fans in the threads we read are starting to migrate to drugstore alternatives.
For shoppers who can tolerate the price and the lottery, the consensus says this is still the most precise pen-tip liquid liner in the category. For everyone else, the picks below are cheaper and increasingly competitive.
- Pull gently on the upper corner of the eye area to stretch and smooth the eye before lining with the Stay All Day Liquid Liner
- Apply the liner as close to the lashes as possible
- A product of the USA
- Goes on smoothly without skipping, smudging, or pulling
I've been using stila stay all day for ages, but it's getting unsustainable for how expensive it is. I do really thick eyeliner and it's hard to find one that ...
Lately every eyeliner I've ordered in the past four five months the formula seems super watery and doesn't last as long.
Trust tier reflects our editorial assessment of the source, not the individual quote. Hover for the rationale. See how we tier sources →
“Stila Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner Review: Smudge-Proof, All” · Day ...
If the consensus convinced you
Check current price on Amazon
Pricing and availability change frequently. Tap through to confirm before buying.