Concept2 RowErg Indoor Rowing Machine - PM5 Monitor, Device Holder, Adjustable Air Resistance, Easy Storage

Across the reviewers we read, the Concept2 RowErg is treated as the reference point every other rowing machine is measured against. r/Rowing and r/concept2 threads repeatedly describe it as "the gold standard," praising its near-indestructible build, minimal maintenance and strong resale value, with one community member calling it "probably the best piece of workout equipment that I own." The PM5 monitor draws particular praise for Bluetooth connectivity to apps like ErgData, Zwift and EXR and for delivering universally comparable, calibrated data — a recurring reason reviewers prefer it over cheaper rivals.

The criticisms are consistent and honest. r/concept2 users note the seat cushioning is "almost nonexistent" and uncomfortable on long rows, and that the air flywheel is "pretty loud" — louder than a water rower. Some also point out the PM5 is functional rather than a flashy touchscreen, and you must manually adjust the damper. A Walmart aggregate of 3.7 stars sits oddly against Amazon's 4.9, a discrepancy worth flagging, though the weight of high-trust community sentiment lands firmly positive.

The overall picture from the reviewers is that this is the safe, do-everything choice: not the cheapest, not the quietest, but the most durable and data-accurate machine in the category.