Are Arcade1Up cabinets worth it compared to a real arcade machine?

Across reviewers we read, the consensus is that Arcade1Up cabinets are a nostalgia-and-decor purchase, not a replacement for commercial-grade arcades. Specialist subreddit threads consistently flag mushy buttons, sticks that feel only 'so-so,' and 16:9 LCDs that letterbox 4:3 games. For most home buyers wanting a few classic titles, the value is fine; for serious pinball or fighting enthusiasts, an authentic cabinet or PC-based MAME setup is the better fit.