Are Darn Tough socks really worth the $25 price?

The consensus across verified-purchase reviewers at rei.com and long-running BuyItForLife threads is yes, primarily because of the unconditional lifetime warranty and 10+ year real-world durability reports. The main pushback in specialist communities is that the dense knit takes longer to dry overnight on thru-hikes, and a vocal minority on r/BuyItForLife says newer pairs don't last as long as older ones.