Are Kate Spade jewelry cases higher quality than Amazon brands?

Reviewers are split. Verified-purchase ratings on the small Kate Spade hard-shell cases run very high (4.8 on the polka-dot version), and threads on r/handbags and r/marshallsfinds praise the jewelry cases specifically, even from posters skeptical of the broader Kate Spade handbag line. The quality complaints in those same threads are almost always directed at the bags, not the small accessories.