Are umbrella-style windshield shades worth it?

Mixed. Reviewers on r/LivingSpacesHub and r/TeslaModelY praise the Nmoiss and EcoNour umbrella designs for fast deployment and compact storage, but r/priusdwellers and r/Ioniq5 threads flag fit issues—they often miss several inches at the top of the windshield on cars with raked glass, and some owners worry about dash scuffing from the central pole.