How much should I spend on a dog toy?

Verified-purchase reviewers consistently note that price doesn't correlate cleanly with longevity — sub-$10 picks like the Benebone Wishbone and the Best Pet Supplies crinkle plush show up in long-running rotations, while pricier 'indestructible' toys sometimes fail within days. Buying one well-reviewed toy per play style (chew, fetch, puzzle, plush) tends to outperform buying many cheap variations.