Is heavier flatware always better?

Heavier flatware generally feels more premium and is harder to bend, and r/BuyItForLife commenters consistently prefer sets with noticeable heft. But weight alone doesn't guarantee good steel — some heavy sets still rust, and some lighter, well-finished sets hold up for decades. Steel grade (18/10), finishing quality at the tines and edges, and brand track record are stronger predictors than weight by itself.