Is the cheap Amazon thermal printer really as good as a Rollo?

Specialist communities in our data are split. Multiple r/EtsySellers and r/Etsy posters say a $30–$70 Phomemo/Nelko/JADENS works fine for low volume. But r/eBaySellerAdvice and r/Flipping users who've owned both consistently say the Rollo's build quality, roller mechanism, and label-feed reliability are noticeably better over multi-year use.