Steel toe vs. composite toe: which should I buy?

Across the reviewers we read, composite toes (as in the KEEN Cincinnati, BRUNT Sullivan, and Ariat Rebar Lift) are praised for being noticeably lighter and for not conducting heat or cold, which matters in extreme temperatures and around electrical hazards. Steel toes like the Timberland PRO Pit Boss are typically cheaper and offer a thinner, roomier profile for the same protection, but several community posts note they transmit cold and can set off metal detectors. Both meet ASTM impact standards when properly rated.