Which eyeliner lasts longest without smudging?

Verified-purchase reviewers and r/MakeupAddiction threads consistently point to Stila Stay All Day and Maybelline Hyper Easy as the longest-wearing liquid liners, while SOSHE Precision and L'Oreal Infallible Grip dominate the gel-pencil long-wear conversation. Results vary heavily by skin type, oily and hooded lids see significantly more transfer regardless of formula.