VerdictAI

Beauty & Personal Care · Eyeliners

Why does my liquid eyeliner dry out so quickly?

Reviewer consensus

This is one of the most common complaints across retailer reviews for both Stila and Maybelline pens. Reviewers report felt-tip liners drying out within weeks, often blamed on formula changes or air exposure. Storing pens horizontally and capping firmly is the most-repeated user fix.

See the full eyeliners ranking →