WaterRower Club Rowing Machine with S4 BLE Monitor | USA Made Water Rower | Original Handcrafted Erg Row Machine for Home Use &…
WaterRower
Best for
Best overall
Amazon rating
Amazon aggregate, one input among many in the Verdict Score
Based on 1 trusted source
Current price
$1,398.00
Updated May 17, 2026 · 1 min read
Sources behind this verdict
10 reviewers weighted by source trust
The consensus
What reviewers found
Synthesized across the trust-weighted source mix below.
Across the reviewers we read, the WaterRower Club is the most well-rounded water rower on the market. garagegymreviews.com calls it a 'sophisticated rower' that delivers on performance while looking sharp in a home gym, and barbend.com positions the solid-oak mid-range WaterRower as offering the benefits of the best rowing machines 'without being an eyesore.' The water flywheel design is repeatedly described in r/Rowing and r/waterrower threads as the closest indoor approximation of an on-water stroke. The Club differentiates itself from the cheaper Natural primarily through its higher seat height and rubberized rail, which r/orangetheory commenters note is essentially the same machine used in their studios.
What reviewers liked
- High-trust expert consensus from garagegymreviews.com and barbend.com on build quality and rowing feel
- Specialist-community praise for parts availability and long-term durability on r/waterrower
- Higher seat height than the Natural makes entry/exit easier, per r/orangetheory commenters
- Strong 4.6/350 Amazon verified-rating base
Where it falls short
- S4 monitor is described on r/waterrower as basic compared to Concept2's PM5
- Single-rail design generates some seat noise; r/waterrower users note a dual-rail model is 'more zen'
- r/waterrower notes the S4 footplates can feel narrow for wider users
- At $1,398 it's a significant step up from budget wooden foldables
Across the reviewers we read, the WaterRower Club is the most well-rounded water rower on the market. garagegymreviews.com calls it a 'sophisticated rower' that delivers on performance while looking sharp in a home gym, and barbend.com positions the solid-oak mid-range WaterRower as offering the benefits of the best rowing machines 'without being an eyesore.' The water flywheel design is repeatedly described in r/Rowing and r/waterrower threads as the closest indoor approximation of an on-water stroke.
The Club differentiates itself from the cheaper Natural primarily through its higher seat height and rubberized rail, which r/orangetheory commenters note is essentially the same machine used in their studios. Specialist-community consensus on r/waterrower is that WaterRowers are 'extremely well built' with replacement parts that are 'easily replaced and fairly priced,' which matters at a 1,400-dollar price point. The S4 BLE monitor draws mixed reviews on r/waterrower, where users describe it as 'fine for starting people' but lacking the granularity of higher-end systems.
Where reviewers disagree: a YouTube critique titled 'Why I Will Never Buy a WaterRower' surfaces in the signals as a counterweight, and r/waterrower threads acknowledge the S4 isn't a Concept2 PM5 in data fidelity. None of the high-trust sources treat that as disqualifying.
- Highlight 1
- The Original Waterrower - Handcrafted and Built to Last: Designed in the mid '80s by Yale and US National Team Rower John Duke. WaterRower continues to combine stylish design, handcrafted workmanship, our unique WaterFlywheel resistance and ethically sourced materials create the world's finest rowing simulator
- Highlight 2
- Made in the USA - Hand-built in Rhode Island; all timber used in the manufacture of wooden WaterRower rowing machines is sourced from sustainably managed hardwood forests in the Appalachian Mountains. The Club is handcrafted in solid Ash and stained for color
- Highlight 3
- Smooth - Water rowers use a water-filled flywheel to provide resistance as you row. The resistance is created by the paddle-like blades of the flywheel moving through the water, creating a smooth and natural resistance that closely resembles the feeling of rowing on water. Like water, the harder you fight, the more resistance you get
- Highlight 4
- Burn calories in a short time - There are many benefits to rowing. It is a low impact cardiovascular exercise that puts less stress on your joints. Full body workout that includes your legs, core, back and arms. Perfect for all fitness levels. This water rowing machine targets all major muscle groups (84 percent of total muscle mass)
- Highlight 5
- Dimensions - 82" L x 20" H x 22" W / weight: 103.5 lbs (with water). Easily store it on end
Pedals: the S4 has some bad fame regarding feet being too close together (only works well for people on the skinny side of the body shape ...
I have an 'Original Series' model. Very solid construction and it looks beautiful. Massive plus: the soothing sound it makes. You can also rent ...
Trust tier reflects our editorial assessment of the source, not the individual quote. Hover for the rationale. See how we tier sources →
“WaterRower Series 4 Rowing Machine” · Review & Demo
If the consensus convinced you
Check current price on Amazon
Pricing and availability change frequently. Tap through to confirm before buying.